There’s a great scene in The Shawshank Redemption where Andy Dufresne, in his role as accountant for the warden, ends up filing the taxes on behalf of the entire prison staff. Then, the movie skips forward a year, where an entire softball team waits patiently for their turn with Andy. The warden had scheduled the softball games to ensure his fellow penal officers had the opportunity to use a genuine accountant, and a free one at that. With W2 filing imminent, it’s useful to look at this scene in a broader context. Even an awful person like the warden knew how valuable a good accountant is for filing ones’ taxes. The tax code is an impenetrable mess of a document. It’s very difficult to even understand short sentences on a W2. Taxes, in a word, are a pain.
There are indications that this may not always be the case. There’s no hope for the tax code to be simplified, nor re-written in plainer English. However, what Andy Dufresne did for those government employees was a long, involved and complicated process where ours is usually just putting a few numbers in the appropriate box on our W2 form. We’ve come many, many leaps forward in this area. This may not be in the golden age of taxes, but consider: electronic W2s, online filing, and a government branch that’s accessible via the Internet instead of long lines. Twenty years ago an IRS audit was a completely different process than it is today.
An unintended side effect of all of this is that accountants have less to do than ever before. While millions of people use the Internet for their taxes and have online W2s, the companies who made their money preparing W2s and other forms have been fighting to stay alive. That turn has lead the largest such company in the country, H&R Block, to engage in allegedly predatory lending tactics they call “rapid refunds.” Since most people can file their own W2 with little effort, H&R made millions by doubling as a bank.
As detailed in the Gaston Gazette, federal regulators forced the high-interest lending practice to stop this year. The effective APR rate for loans like this, backed by tax refunds, can be up to 500% in some cases. H&R Block looks to lose the $146 million they made last year with rapid refunds, and maybe more from the resulting stock drop. However, a few others like Jackson Hewitt and Liberty quickly announced they will continue to offer anticipatory loans. There are many in the United States who desperately need money, and these tax preparation companies will happily oblige.
Electronic W2s let the public bypass the entire industry of tax preparation, if they so choose. Certainly you don’t need a live person to help you anymore. After you file your online W2 with the IRS, it takes between eight and fourteen days before your refund is issued, which is fairly impressive for a government bureaucracy.
photo courtesy Burger Baroness










